Penitent

Penitent (n.)

Joseph Duemer has been musing about writing as therapy. One of his students proposed that a writer must have an unspecified, though specific relationship with language in order for writing to be therapeutic. Scientific research suggests otherwise. I encountered some of it while taking a class in “Writing and Healing.” My interest in the class was purely theoretical. Like Duemer, I have a certain hesitation in declaring that writing to sort out trauma is universally productive. However, the research of Joseph Pennebaker which I wrote about during the class is worth bringing up, as is the link contributed by a reader in response to that entry to Pennebaker’s homepage.

The interesting thing about this thread right now for me is that Pennebaker’s work undercuts a lot of Foucault’s argument in History of Sexuality. Pennebaker claims that we have a physiological need to confess. Foucault argues that the apparatus of the confessional is genealogically related to the construction of our concept of identity. Confession, far from being a natural compulsion, is a societal mandate in Western nations. I had some difficulty with that the last time I read the book.

I’m still not sure, but I suspect that the answer isn’t either/or. However, the healing relationship poised by Pennebaker is not contingent on written expression. Therefore, one need not write out their confession, or even share it with another, for it to have a positive effect of releasing tension. The basic idea is that being penitent releases some of the energy that the body expends suppressing thoughts of trauma. Other theory I read at the time goes deeper, suggesting that the temporal ordering of trauma (centered in the amygdala) provided by linguistic transfer (by nature temporal, whether spoken or written) is of great importance in the assimilation of emotion.

The apparatus of the confessional proposed by Foucault does exist. However, this does not mean that we are not by nature penitent as an apparatus of self-healing. The ordering of experience is a fascinating phenomenon. There is no evidence to suggest that the impulse to confess might not come from both directions— both within, and without. And I would disagree with any suggestion that it requires a certain “competence” to be effective. Obviously, if it were a life-skill that could be codified and taught, someone would be teaching it already. I think we all set our own boundaries, and make it up as we go along (excepting Catholics, of course).

3 thoughts on “Penitent”

  1. More metaphor meanderings

    (Disclaimer: this will definitely make no sense without reading yesterday’s post first. It may well make no sense at all to anyone except me.) I always arrive at the party after everyone’s moved on. So no sooner have I manufactured…

Comments are closed.