More Deathblogging

It was with great sadness that I read that Mr. Wizard is dead. My lovely wife was stricken as well. Though we are separated by many years physically, mentally there is a connection that passes through the Mr. Wizard show. Watching all the obits pile up on Richard Rorty, I was most pleased by Jurgen Habermas’s remembrance. It seemed more personal somehow.

It was also with some shock that I learned via Krause about Rudolf Arnheim’s death. There isn’t much out there yet. You’d think that living to 102 would grant you some coverage by the press. Besides the Ann Arbor paper, the only mention so far seems to be in the Washington Post. I was rereading Visual Thinking a few months ago, and had tabbed out these paragraphs in his chapter on “Visual Education” as worthwhile:

In the arts, then, the student meets the world of visual appearances as symbolic of significant patterns and forces in a manner quite different from the scientific use of sensory information. Sights that are accidental with regard to objective situation become valid as carriers of meaningful patterns and can be called truthful or false, appropriate or inappropriate by standards not applicable to the statements of science. But art not only exploits the variety of appearances, it also affirms the validity of the individual outlook and thereby admits a further dimension of variety. Since the shapes of art do not primarily bear witness to the objective nature of the things for which they stand, they can reflect individual interpretation and invention.

Both art and science are bent on the understanding of the forces that shape existence, and both call for an unselfish dedication to what is. Neither of them can tolerate capricious subjectivity because both are subject to the criteria of truth. Both require precision, order, and discipline because no comprehensible statement can be made without these. Both accept the sensory world as what the Middle Ages called the signatura rerum, the signature of things, but in quite different ways. The medieval physicians believed that yellow flowers cure jaundice and that bloodstone stops hemorrhage; and in a less literal sense modern science still searches the appearance of things for symptoms of their characters and virtues. The artist may use those yellows and reds as equally revealing images of radiance or passion; and the arts welcome the multiplicity of world views, the variety of personal and cultural styles, because the diversity of response is as legitimate as an aspect of reality as that of the things themselves. (300-301)

Carry that Weight

snapshot of google maps

Lower 9th Ward of New Orleans, according to Google Maps on 4/1/2007 — not an April Fool’s joke.

I was more than a little disappointed a few days ago when Badger pointed out an AP story about Google Maps’ rosy nostalgia. A quick search brought up another view of a barge in the lower 9th ward. It’s hard to say if they are the same physically, but one can be reasonably certain that the second view (stored beneath the fold for fear of linkrot) is a more accurate view of the state of affairs in January 2007.

Continue reading “Carry that Weight” →

Figural Realism

I have long thought that the relationship between literary discourse (where writing is supposed to be free and even abandoned) and historical discourse (where factuality, realism, and rational commonsense are supposed to prevail) provides a microcosm of Western thought’s effort to relate imagination (the vision of what might be) and commonsense (the thought of what is the case, what goes without saying). In trying to show the literariness of historical writing and the realism of literary writing, I have sought to establish “mutual implicativeness” (Windelbrand’s term) of their respective techniques of composition, description, imitation, narration, and demonstration. Each in its way is an example of a distinctively Western practice, not so much of representation as of presentation, which is to say, production rather than reproduction or mimesis. (ix)

Hayden White’s concern with presentation and production rather than reproduction or simulation highlights much of what wanted to mark in my previous comparison of quotes from Klett, Dingus and Baudrillard. But there is an interesting inversion. While “theory” seems closer to the aims of “history,” the artistic discourse of Klett and Dingus seems far more presentational than reproductive — even though they are engaged in a careful exercise in imitation. Baudrillard, the “academic” is the literary one concerned with representation and simulation. This seems to be a profound pitfall; a self-conscious irony permeating historical (cultural) criticism.

Writing Studies

I’ve not entered into the carnival circuit before, but I would like to offer some thoughts regarding John Trimbur’s Changing the question: Should writing be studied?. Some responses (at least so far) seem to have relatively little to do with the substance of the article, but are nonetheless stimulating.

To begin, Jeff Rice conflates Trimbur’s arguments with his own argument about networks: “‘The social relations and bodies of knowledge’ are central to any ‘thing’ we name or categorize as ‘writing.’” Trimbur’s question is branded as “odd” because, (at least as I understand Jeff’s claim) writing cannot be “studied” without studying the surrounding networks/economies of production and consumption. This point is easily granted, but seems commonplace. More intriguing is his closing reflection on Barthes A Lover’s Discourse:

Each conversation brings an ordinary, insistent, or occasional relationship to the reading or writing. Those conversations, implicit and explicit, can occur in a shopping list (which is one example Trimbur provides from his textbook; a writing some students dispute and label irrelevant) or on a website or in an encounter, or in a book, and so on. This writing, however, is not, as Trimbur offers, symbolic. Its process or flow does not represent another experience or encounter. It is writing itself. The challenge is to ask: how does one generate or maintain such relations with references? How does one teach that writing within an already established network that poses references as proof or confirmation?

The conflation attempted here does not make nearly as much sense to me. The methodology deployed to explore the discourse of lovers is not even vaguely interchangeable with the context of academic writing studies. I am a huge fan of Barthes; the “process or flow” of the discourse of lovers does not represent another experience or encounter, but this is not equivalent to a lack of symbolic content. Indeed, such discourse is at its root symbolic in an iconic sense:

Continue reading “Writing Studies” →

Cultural Dreams

We live in the age of the image.
Today, no other realm of culture displays so much power
than that of the image.
Words, music, literature,
books, newspapers, rock’n roll, theatre…
nothing comes even close
to the authority of moving images, in cinema and television.

Why is it that today, not only in Europe,
but all over the world,
“going to the pictures”
is synonymous with
“seeing an American film”?!

Because the Americans realized long ago
what moves people most
and what gets them dreaming.
And they radically implemented that knowledge.
The whole “American Dream”
is really an invention of cinema,
and it is now being dreamed by the whole world.

I don’t want to discredit this,
but merely ask the question,
“Who is dreaming the European Dream?”
Or better: How are we encouraged to dream it?

Wim Wenders, “Giving Europe a Soul?”

Lately, I’ve become obsessed with “regionalism” as an artistic movement of the late 1930s (Grant Wood, et. al. + the Federal Writers Project). The thing that most people call “American” is actually more of a function of the cultural values of hot spots such as California and New York, or even Texas. These values don’t necessarily coincide with the vast majority of the country. The agreement on what “American” means (for better or worse) is a function of mass rather than local medias.

This hasn’t always been the case. Regionalism is usually branded as “thinly disguised nationalism.” The arc towards a “European Dream” subsumes the “regionalism” of the nation-states involved; it’s the end of regionalism all over again. But I think its loss comes at a dear price, it’s ultimately the death of the local in favor of the “general.” This general perspective is the property of those who talks the loudest or acts the rudest, rather than any sort of true consensus—such “universal” agreement seems impossible.

But most significantly, I think, we lack an awareness of just what a “local” media might entail. America had that in the newspaper explosion of the late nineteenth century, but lost it with the advent of mass media.

Reading In

Last night, I attended a panel composed of Jeff L. Rosenheim, Neil Selkirk, Elisabeth Sussman and Elisabeth Carpenter at the Walker Art Center on the eve of the opening of Diane Arbus Revelations. The motivation for assembling the show and monograph, according to Sussman, was the fact that although a huge stack of articles have been published about Diane Arbus (pronounced Dee-anne), these speculations really tell us nothing about her. Most of them are “pure rubbish.” Each one generally reveals the particular perverse interest the critic has taken in the work—on the whole, they add less than nothing to our understanding.

When the Q&A started, it became clear that the main reason why a lot of people attended the panel was to query the panelists about the nature of her unhappy life and suicide. Such matters, as Selkirk pointed out, are completely peripheral and disconnected with the work. Selkirk, who knew her briefly and is the official printer for her estate, suggested that we read and listen to her commentaries about her own work. She does not seem depressed or unhappy. The panelists refused to read anything into her work about her suicide, or to speculate on its cause. Life is complicated, Selkirk suggested. Arbus didn’t like museums much; Selkirk mentioned that Arbus commented on how “clean” they were.

“Reading in” seems like a fine sport for those in the clean room. This seems a poor substitute for reading itself. Mark Woods juxtaposed the quote from Emily Thompson I posted about soundscapes yesterday with an article by Jonathan Flatley using the same point of departure from Marx. The two authors couldn’t land further apart. What intrigued me about Thompson is that for her, air is material and real. For Flatley, air is speculative. From a critical distance, he reads a lot into things. For example:

Continue reading “Reading In” →

Indigenous Postcards


from my collection

This postcard, and the ones below the fold, are “vernacular” in multiple ways. They are printed on Kodak postcard paper with no imprint or studio stamp, so they come from some enterprising local entrepreneur rather than a major company. There is no copyright notice or other marking, no date, no identification beyond their common topoi—Wisconsin Dells, Winnebago, Indian, etc. inscribed on the face

Continue reading “Indigenous Postcards” →

Monumental Vernaculars

Crazy Horse
A crazy monument (or a monument to crazy)

The differing roots and uses of the term “vernacular” are fascinating to me. Taken from the Latin vernaculus, the OED traces the original meaning from the seventeenth century as pertaining to the “domestic, native, indigenous.” In the mid-nineteenth century, it was applied in opposition to the monumental in a curious definition:

6. Of arts, or features of these: Native or peculiar to a particular country or locality. spec. in vernacular architecture, architecture concerned with ordinary domestic and functional buildings rather than the essentially monumental.

The differentiation doesn’t hold up well under stress. Blowing up mountains seems fairly indigenous to South Dakota. The crowds that come participate in their own sort of tourist vernacular: they photograph these things. The more monumental something is, the more we feel authorized and perhaps even compelled to photograph it. In short, such sites create a tourist “vernacular.” The terms are slippery at best, but those who undertake these pilgrimages to the middle of nowhere are theoroi bringing back the “evidence” of witnessing in the form of souvenirs, and in snapshots which establish their position within the scene. Thus, vernacular architecture (the commonplace) is unsuited in fulfilling the memorial function—to create a sense of shared (domestic or vernacular) memory, witnesses rely on the monumental.

Krista directed me to Shiny, Pointy, and Tall. It seems that I’m not the only one who is struck by how some objects, like the Crazy Horse Monument, drive people to photograph them. This monument exists primarily in the minds of the spectators; there isn’t much there. But with enough props, and enough imagination, you can see that horse riding off into the sunset. It’s all in how you frame it.

*In an odd coincidence, I notice that the SPE Mid Atlantic Conference is themed as “Vernacular Spectacular”. I wish I were closer to Philadelphia, John Waters is the keynote and I’d love to go!