Sad


from You are Here, The Ed Ruscha Monument by Kent Twitchell.

Via NewsGrist comes some sad news. This mural has been painted over. The LA Times story reads:

Twitchell, who lives and works in Los Angeles, said he had contacted a lawyer and planned to file a lawsuit.

The artist said he was alerted by conservationist Nathan Zakheim, who had been in the early stages of restoring the work and had gone by to see it Friday morning. “I went to get more pictures and take samples,” Zakheim said, “and guess what: It was completely painted out.”

Zakheim said the piece is nearly unrecoverable.

Ruscha’s books, particularly Every Building on Sunset Strip were a tremendous influence on me. This is sad, but inevitable given the sorry fate granted most roadside attractions. Maybe Twitchell will make a buck from the contractor’s ineptitude.

Buffalo Bill’s attic

Buffalo Bill Museum
The Le Claire, Iowa, museum show.

Compared to the wide open spaces and manicured paths of Scout Ranch, the Buffalo Bill Museum in LeClaire, Iowa, takes a decidedly more chaotic and claustrophobic turn. Some clue can be found on its simple web site: “and other famous people” should be amended to read “other people and things.” Most of the objects and people commemorated here have nothing to do with the name attached to the museum; it’s as if an entire town cleaned its attic and sent it to this nondescript brick building for safekeeping.

Continue reading “Buffalo Bill’s attic” →

Velvet Ropes

Buffalo Bill's Barn
No roaming or running allowed— stay behind the rope.

The summer home of Buffalo Bill, Scout Ranch in North Platte, Nebraska, is a spacious and specious sort of experience. The home is tidy, and an attendant waits in the back room to take your money. The dining room is where we transacted business. The portraits on the wall gave a kind of warmth to the place. It was soon apparent that the warmth was illusory; the dining room was the only room freely accessible to intruders (tourists). Returning to the front hallway, the living room was protected by a velvet rope. So was the rest of the house. There was no roaming inside. The path was prescribed.

Upstairs past the sitting room, the pattern really developed. Much of the house was behind glass, an assortment of curios rather than lived objects. The bedrooms were tidy, and I transgressed the boundaries by gently removing the velvet rope from my path to photograph the dummy in the hall. The back stairs led out to the open, to the coke machine, restrooms that smelled like any typical campground, and eventually the barn.

Another attendant sat at the door. The downstairs was filled with artifacts and images, stretched down the 100 feet or so of walls like a giant cowboy Louvre. I especially liked the lasso made from Christmas lights. Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show was certainly a cheesy affair, but this monument was of a different sort: domesticity behind glass and velvet ropes. I’m not sure he would approve—I mean, where’s the action, the display of skill?

The restless adolescent buffalo were the only source of movement. A sign in the upstairs of the barn read “please restrain your children from running.”

Speaking the Vernacular

Gradually finding my way back to things, I’m trying to put my finger on why I have serious problems with the idea of “image vernaculars,” as opposed to the much more common construct of “vernacular images”. I didn’t have the time to go into this when I first commented on the RSA panel “Visual Rhetoric and Visual Culture.” While this was one of the best presentations I saw, it was troubling on a number of levels beyond the issue of novelty.

The other presenters were Robin E. Jensen, “Reading Sex: Progressive Era Image Vernaculars and Sexual Education Campaigns,” Kassie Lamp, “An Innocent Face: Image Vernaculars in the Murder of Helen Jewett and Trial of Richard P. Robinson” and Katherine Mack, “Victims and Perpetrators Look Back: The Visual Rhetorics of South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission.” Each of the panelists (including the previously mentioned Michelle Gibbons) were guests at a special visual rhetoric workshop at Northwestern hosted by Robert Hariman (the panel’s chair), which included Cara Finnegan (the respondent for this panel) and Kevin DeLuca. The research presented was novel and important; the theoretical framework is what seemed anemic to me. Note the recurrence of “image vernaculars” in the paper titles. I was going to apply for this workshop, but the opportunity presented itself to teach a photography class—a time conflict. I learned a lot teaching that class, but I suspect the workshop would have been really fun too.

I’ve delayed writing much about the panel as a whole because I wanted to revisit Cara Finnegan’s article “ Recognizing Lincoln: Image Vernaculars in Nineteenth-Century Visual Culture” to be clear on just what “image vernaculars” are supposed to be.

Continue reading “Speaking the Vernacular” →

Negative Creep

I wrote briefly about the first RSA panel I attended last Saturday. Each time I try to engage with these things, I get increasingly recursive. Most roads lead to nowhere. Doublespeak bothers me. Creating new words when there are perfectly good old ones to use also bothers me. Several papers at the conference gestured at Mark Augé. When I asked questions, Gregory Ulmer was also cited as a fountainhead for these “non” concepts. The general thrust (obviously lacking nuance) of this first panel, and the second-to-last one I attended on Monday with papers by Collin Brooke, Daniel Smith, Jeff Rice, and Jodie Nicotra was that ideas like “nonplace” and the overthrow of any static relationship (i.e. subject/object, observer/event) must inevitably be productive. In short, they offered a “negative” definition of production bracketing or excluding standard notions of topoi or considerations of place. Another phrasing might be: Never assume the position.

I remarked before about the exclamation of “non-sense” from the crowd at the first panel, but it is hard to ignore it when so many smart people choose to invoke this stuff. I looked at the books, and started to wonder if I needed to read them. Thankfully, I found a nicely explicated article on Augé’s “nonspace” written by Torill Mortensen. The article has helped me land in a place I can understand—the crucial passage is this:

“If a place can be defined as relational, historical and concerned with identity, then a space which cannot be defined as relational, or historical, or concerned with identity will be a non-place.” (p. 77-78)

Continue reading “Negative Creep” →

Heads

It takes a lot of time to record commentary, but there are still some things I wanted to note from the second day of panels at RSA. The panel on “Visual Rhetoric and Visual Culture” chaired by Robert Hariman embraced three fine and polished papers. In fact, the presentation was so smooth it seemed choreographed (other than the chair’s unfashionably late arrival). About the first paper . . .

Michelle Gibbons’s “How to Look at Heads: The American Phrenological Journal and Nineteenth Century Visual Culture” made a bold claim at the onset: previous scholarship has failed to address the bidirectional nature of phrenological and physiognomic claims. In other words, phrenology didn’t just read head-bumps, it sought to modify the shapes and features of heads by modifying the behavior of the owners of said heads.

Perhaps that’s true in rhetorical/speech communication scholarship—it isn’t true in American Studies/Literature. Her presentation reminded me somewhat of “Monica Lewinsky, The Music Man, and The Scarlet Letter,” a lecture delivered flamboyantly by Chris Castiglia that I attended in 2002. Besides belting out show-tunes, Castiglia made a pretty compelling case that phrenology and physiognomy in the nineteenth century externalized not only positive virtues, but also sins so that they could be cast-off. Behavior modification, not just interpretation, was key to Castiglia’s presentation. I don’t write this to undermine the core of Gibbons’s paper, because her presentation and research was hardcore and specific, but merely to suggest that perhaps “great minds think alike.” To be fair, Castiglia was concerned with, as he puts it in a related article, “the redisposition of delinquent interiority” while Gibbons seems more interested in the visuality of these claims. Fun stuff. I can’t help but think of a Talking Heads song, “Seen and Not Seen”:

Continue reading “Heads” →

The final frontier

Newton, KS
Shell Station, Newton, KS

Arrived in Memphis yesterday, but had to sit most of the day out. Chills, fever, and general nastiness. After regaining some equilibrium, got up this morning to see a panel on “Postmodern Variations on a Theme of Agency.” R. Scot Barnett delivered a paper titled “Spatializing Rhetorical Agency: Capacities for Action in Non-Place” or something like it (I can’t accurately remember who changed the titles of their papers and who didn’t). Barnett’s paper was interesting to me because it suggested that defining spaces in terms of “presence” or “lack” did not address the way that space is “performed.” The theme of possession that is part-and-parcel of these conventionalized modes of thinking about space misses key aspects of the way that we commonly encounter space.

Using the term “non-place” set up some fierce debates in the Q&A afterward, particularly in regard to the third paper by John Mucklebauer about Levinas (the title on that one changed severely and I didn’t note it). “Locative Art and Rhetorical Agency” by David Rieder hit on some of the same cylinders. Using some pomo critics that I’m not familiar with, they suggested that regularized spaces like airports, Starbucks, etc. promote a feeling of “non-place.” It didn’t ring true for me. The thought that occurred to me (which I said nothing about, due to a sore throat) is that these sorts of regularized spaces are much like what Latour called “immutable mobiles,” transportable spaces that make us feel at once “at home” and “displaced.”

This reminded me about taking the photograph (above). The woman inside the gas station wanted to know what I was taking pictures of—I answered “wide open spaces.” Every space is a little different, and lots of places do not feature empty space. The idea of a non-space (according to the academic who verged on heckling) is absolutely ludicrous. If it’s not in space, we can’t conceive of it.

Carolyn Miller’s paper in this same session forged a distinction between “potential” and “kinetic” energy—a distinction as difficult to conceptualize as “non-space.” The primary way I could translate it to myself is the distinction between the inertia of a moving body and a potential for movement present in a body at rest. When Miller talked about it, kinetic energy seemed like the most positive attribute of human interaction; naming it as inertia places it in a different light.

A friend asked a few days ago: “how many pictures of the back-ass of a gas station can you take?” It seems to me that there are endless variations on the theme of place.

Open

A couple of things.

Watching an interview clip from Neil Young, I started thinking about freedom and the lack of it. Everyone trumpets “freedom of speech,” but there is also an equal and opposite freedom to be silent. Balancing the two is a problem. But more than that, I wonder about losing the “freedom to be wrong.” Most classroom environments tend to snatch that away from you, with little notice of its absence.

Robert Fripp wrote an excellent short introduction to a book of Tony Levin photographs, Road Photos. It creeps into my head at the strangest times. I woke up this morning with one line, (loosely quoted) “A photograph captures aspects of open significance.” The brilliant choice of words here makes this thoroughly packed with meaning. “Aspects” can refer to faces or facets—but it never refers to wholes. “Open” can also be spun through with indeterminate, because although a variety of readings can present themselves, none is comprehensive or exhaustive. But more than that, “open significance” tends to imply that the significance, that is, the status of a photograph as a sign is not fully formed. In short, a photograph is raw— an unfinished repository of aspects which may or may not be signs.

I begin to believe this, although I could be wrong.

Touristic Attitude

While almost all photographers do their share of family photography, many photographers confer upon it other functions which are, in fact, only variants of its archetypal function. The intensification of photographic practice is very closely linked to holidays and tourism, but we should not conclude from this that all photographs taken on holidays or outings can escape being explained by the family function, or that the simple fact of an increase in the number of occasions which may be photographed is enough to determine the appearance of a practice vested with new functions. If the proportion of practitioners is higher among those who have summer holidays than those who have not, this is probably partly due to the fact that photographic practice, like the opportunity of taking holidays, is related to income, but also and particularly because of the fact that the holiday is one of the high points of family life.

In fact, the variations in the objective occasions for taking photographs which are linked, for example, to the length or the location of those holidays do not bring about any noticeable modification in the intensity of the modal practice, because this depends less on incentives such as the beauty of the landscapes or the variety of places visited than on socially defined occasions. Inasmuch as holidays are the occasion of more intense family relations (for example, for people who go to stay with their families) and more frequent social gatherings, it is natural that they should encourage the intensification of a photographic practice that has always had the express function of immortalizing the major events and high points of family life, so that holiday photographs generally remain photographs of the family on holiday.

Moreover, holidays determine the broadening of the range of the photographable and produce a disposition to take photographs which, far from being of different nature from the traditional disposition, is simply an extension of it: in fact, a practice that is so strongly associated with extraordinary occasions that it could be seen as a festive technique is naturally reinforced in a period which marks a break with the everyday environment and the routines of normal life. The adoption of what we might call the touristic attitude means escaping one’s inattentive familiarity with the everyday world, an undifferentiated background against which the forms momentarily separated from everyday preoccupations stand out . From that moment on, everything becomes a source of astonishment, and the travel-guide is a constant call to admiration, a manual of armed and directed perception.

Photography is what one does on holiday, and also what makes a holiday . . .

Pierre Bourdieu, Photography: A Middle-brow Art (1965), p. 35-36