Focus

Although it is ostensibly my field, I always have trouble trying to explain how to exercise good visual sense in designing technical documents. I’ve been working on some new presentations, and have had pretty good luck this semester using multimedia to fight boredom both in my students and myself. I’m not sure if today’s bit went over well, but I liked it. Some unintended connections surfaced.

I used an old Prelinger film on How the Eye Functions (cut into bite-sized clips) to show how contrast, pointers, headings, etc. can manage attention. The drone of the film helps point out how uniformity and regularity can be both a blessing and a curse. In a more modern vein, I used an article about a varioptic lens for cell phones. I think it shows several complementary typefaces and layout devices working together to direct the viewer in a rich reading experience.

Then it dawned on me. The varioptic lens and the eye are pretty similar technologies, really—much more similar than standard lenses, at least. They share the same primary problem of focusing a “camera” with a fixed distance between lens and “film.” What the eye has that the varioptic lens doesn’t is an iris—I wonder if it would help sharpen or improve the performance? I’m not an engineer, I couldn’t say.

But the most interesting optical technology I’ve read about lately is the plenoptic camera. It allows the focus to be adjusted after a picture has been taken. These are exciting times to follow imaging in general. We may not be able to understand pictorial communication all that well, but improvements in the technology seem to suggest that there have been significant leaps forward.

Landscape Gardening: A Definition.

SOME of the Fine Arts appeal to the ear, others to the eye. The latter are the Arts of Design, and they are usually named as three—Architecture, Sculpture and Painting. A man who practices one of these in any of its branches is an artist; other men who work with forms and colors are at the best but artisans. This is the popular belief. But in fact there is a fourth art which has a right to be rated with the others, which is as fine as the finest, and which demands as much of its professors in the way of creative power and executive skill as the most difficult. This is the art whose purpose it is to create beautiful compositions upon the surface of the ground.

The mere statement of its purpose is sufficient to establish its rank. It is the effort to produce organic beauty—to compose a beautiful whole with a number of related parts—which makes a man an artist; neither the production of a merely useful organism nor of a single beautiful detail suffices. A clearly told story or a single beautiful word is not a work of art—only a story told in beautifully connected words. A solidly and conveniently built house, if it is nothing more, is not a work of architecture, nor is an isolated stone, however lovely in shape and surface. A delightful tint, a graceful line, does not make a picture; and though the painter may reproduce ugly models he must put some kind of beauty into the reproduction if it is to be esteemed above any other manufactured article—if not beauty of form, then beauty of color or of meaning or at least of execution. Similarly, when a man disposes the surface of the soil with an eye to crops alone he is an agriculturist; when he grows plants for their beauty as isolated objects he is a horticulturist; but when he disposes ground and plants together to produce organic beauty of effect, he is an artist with the best.

Continue reading “Landscape Gardening: A Definition.” →

Likeness Causeth Liking

Numerous myrmecologists have studied the reciprocal behavior of ants and plant-lice (aphids) which, in the course of evolution, seem to have become finely adapted to one another. Certainly, the behavior of both kinds of creatures is altered in each others’ presence. Nutritious food services have become readily available to ant species which extract honeydew from the excrement of the lice.

Aphids, by sinking their extended proboscis into the vascular tissue of the plants, gain direct access to their juices, and exude through the anus the surplus of the digested sap they have taken in. The liquid is rich in sugar (although poor in nitrogen). The worker ants crave to drink the unutilized, undigested honeydew. Their access to this nourishment is thus indirect: they “milk” the aphids; this means that the ants pat the abdomen of the aphids with their antennae tips, a tickling which causes the lice to exude a drop of syrup. Aphids thus managed by ants thrive. Little wonder that Linnaeus called the aphids ants’ cows.

Nobody quite understands why, instead of devouring the aphids, the foraging ants treat them with ritual courtesy insuring, in general, their survival. The way the ant massages the aphid resembles the way that it habitually begs for food from a nestmate. Intraspecific food-sharing behavior in Formica—how donor or acceptor initiates the sequence leading to regurgitation—has been analyzed in impressive detail, and it is now known that the pattern is a nearly universal one among Formicidae. What still remains uncertain is how the habit became extended into a setting involving two vastly different species.

Continue reading “Likeness Causeth Liking” →

Image-Words

It is generally believed that the “social function of communication is the ensuing of continuity through access to the experiences and ideas of the past, expressed in [loosely speaking] symbols for transmission across space and through time. This is the ‘time-binding’ function of social communication” (Neelameghan 1979:103). Man’s time-binding ability arises from his usage of “language, number, gesture, picture and other symbolic forms” enabling him to transcend the limitations of inherited characteristics and the seemingly insurmountable barrier of “time.” It should be noted, in passing, that an era will come when messages vitally important to the race, affecting its survival, will be transmissible by microsurgical intervention with man’s molecular blueprint, but the technology required for this form of temporal communication is far from available yet.

Thomas Sebeok, I Think I Am A Verb, 152, (1987).

We are, for better or worse, stuck with communicating primarily through words, images, and gestures.. Jogged by a post at 2 Blowhards, I wanted to jot down a relevant bit from Sebeok regarding “messages” crossing the supposed divide behind linguistic and alinguistic communication. I have long suspected that it’s a matter of inflection rather than any alteration or intermingling of codes between media. Even the sense of smell can get into the act:

Continue reading “Image-Words” →

Divorce

Discussion of the separation (read paragone, or war) between verbal and visual ways of knowing seems to have ossified in the modern era. Tom has the perfect quote on the subject from Matisse: “He who wishes to devote himself to painting must begin by cutting out his tongue.” W.J.T Mitchell has written about the great divide obsessively, and lately I’ve been digging into Barbara Stafford’s work regarding the rise and fall of “rational recreations” meant to tickle the ocular nerve. The separation seems to be a given, the possibility of its impermanence is not discussed nearly as often.

Along with the “persistence of vision” there are a number of key particles that simply drift about and reemerge in new ways. Morphemes like -graph, -type, -scope and -horama may hibernate for brief spans, but they always seem to come back into the lexicon to do the bidding of culture. Alan Trachtenberg has claimed that photography emerged as a keyword in the mid-nineteenth century which carries with it connotations that were ill-defined and contradictory at first, before they resolved into the cluster of properties we associate with “photographic realism.” I think he’s right. But I think I’d like to push that further. Not only have individual coinages fit some sort of cultural need, but the particles themselves are pressed into service to describe reconfigured modes of practice.

The divorce of visual and verbal is always temporary. They usually remarry with varying degrees of success.

Drink to me only with thine eyes

Note: If television’s a babysitter, the internet’s a drunk librarian who won’t shut up.

Must look for Theology and the Scientific Imagination from the Middle Ages to the Seventeenth Century. It would be great to be able to cite Dr. Funkenstein in a paper someday.

Martin Jay gestures at Funkenstein in Downcast Eyes as a footnote following this passage:

Zeno’s paradox which so perplexed Greek thought, shows how beholden it was to a detemporalized notion of reality (a central target, as we will see, of the French antiocularcentric discourse that began with Bergson’s critique of Zeno). Greek science, which was crowned by optics, was also incapable of dealing successfully with motion, in particular with the problem of acceleration.

Funkenstein evidently discusses the attempts to revise Greek thought to account for different sorts of causality—which is also central to the problem of defining a phenomena in an Aristotelian sense. According to Jay, the thesis that Greek thought was occularcentric is contested by William Ivins. For once, I think I agree with Ivins.

Ivins was the first curator of prints at the Library of Congress. He suggested in Prints and Visual Communication that the halftone screen provided images with a “syntax”— I disagree violently. However, according to Jay, in Art and Geometry Ivins claims that the Greeks had a tactile rather than ocular bias. I think this has more merit.

About Face

On a gray afternoon in March 1933, Franklin Delano Roosevelt took the presidential oath of office and inherited a country in profound economic, social, and spiritual trouble. Roosevelt’s task that somber day was to convince a nation already three years into a great economic depression that there was a reason to hope for better times. In his inaugural address Roosevelt did not sugarcoat the situation; indeed, he pledged to “speak the truth, the whole truth, frankly and boldly.” While President Hoover had often resisted the use of federal sources to alleviate suffering in the states, Roosevelt made it clear that he would mobilize the resources of the federal government to address the economic and social problems of the nation.

Throughout the speech Roosevelt relied heavily on two terms with a distinctly visual inflection: “facing” and “recognizing.” In exhorting Americans to confront their anxieties about the Depression head on, Roosevelt observed that “we face common difficulties,” reminded the audience that “a host of unemployed citizens face the grim problem of existence,” suggested that the problem of unemployment is solvable “if we face it wisely and courageously,” and finally, warned that the nation must “face the arduous days that lie before us.” During the first few years of the Depression, many in government and business had buried their heads in the sand, but Roosevelt asked the American public to turn and “face” the problems of the Depression squarely and courageously. Only when Americans had faced the depression, Roosevelt explained, could they go on to “recognize” what would be necessary for recovery. Roosevelt argued that citizens needed to participate in the “recognition of the falsity of material wealth,” “recognize the overbalance of population in industrial centers,” and understand that national recovery would involve “recognition” of the necessity of interdependence.

Continue reading “About Face” →

Monuments

Wood s Lot posted a few links about monuments as I was sorting some photos. The World Monuments Watch site is certainly significant placed against the background of iconclasm/iconoclash the critical community has marketed in the post 9/11 climate. Monuments interest me, but for a wider range of possibilities.

I came of age in the 1970s, when Lee Friedlander was doing the American Monuments thing. It was influential for many reasons—the reversal of the spectator role (the spectator became the subject), the utter banality of monumental structures in American life, and their ubiquity. In a profound way, Friedlander cut monuments down to size—although for most Americans, they are already pretty diminutive. They are refrigerator magnets or desktop accessories.

During the 60s and 70s, photography made monumental banality a subject of choice. In the 00s, monuments have become just as cliché as a topic for political controversy. Whether discussing the explosive impact of the Taliban on Buddhist tradition, or the flag wavers toppling the monuments of Saddam, it seems as if monuments have been rediscovered. One might as well announce that noses have been discovered as the organizing locus of the face, or eyes as the mirror of the soul.

Continue reading “Monuments” →

Comic

I find it necessary to cast doubts upon the generally accepted theories of man’s basic nature which have been implicit during the past century in our constant overrating of the role of tools and machines in the human economy. I shall suggest that not only was Karl Marx in error in giving the instruments of production a central place and a directive function in human development, but that even the seemingly benign interpretation by Teilhard de Chardin reads back into the whole story of man the narrow technological rationalism of our own age, and projects into the future a final state in which all further possibilities of development would come to an end, because nothing would be left of man’s original nature, which had not been absorbed into, if not suppressed by, the technical organization of intelligence into a universal and omnipotent layer of mind.

. . . I am aware that the following summary must, by its brevity, seem superficial and unconvincing. At best I can only hope to show there are serious reasons for reconsidering the whole picture of human and technical development upon which the present organization of Western society is based.

Lewis Mumford, “Technics and the Nature of Man” (1966)

I was glad to go to a presentation yesterday by Michelle Kendrick which focused on Scott McCloud’s Understanding Comics. I suppose I have to actually buy the book. Like Roxanne, I just don’t get comics (or graphic novels, or theoretical exposition for that matter told in panel-by-panel form). Evidently, McCloud traces the history of comics back to ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia—I don’t buy that at all. I think they are pretty much a twentieth century thing, and don’t see them as the great media revolution which will reshape our consciousness as implied in the title of McCloud’s sequel, Reinventing Comics : How Imagination and Technology Are Revolutionizing an Art Form. Sometimes, history reads more like fiction.

Continue reading “Comic” →