During the final week of March, 1933 Diego Rivera began work on a mural for the lobby of RCA Building One in Rockefeller Center. The title, chosen by the architects of the building, was to be Man at the Crossroads Looking with Hope and High Vision to the Choosing of a New and Better Future (Hamill 164). On May 9, 1933 Rivera was fired. The largely unseen public mural was destroyed approximately a year later, after storms of protest. Public art can be a profoundly moving rhetorical act. The differences of opinion surrounding this artwork reward close scrutiny. It was a complex design failure.
The central actors in this drama were the communist painter Diego Rivera and the Rockefeller family. While in retrospect, the combination seems doomed from the onset, the arrangement made sense at the time. The Rockefeller family heritage is filled with both philanthropy and ruthless capitalist practices. John Rockefeller and his son John D. Rockefeller founded the Rockefeller Foundation in 1913 with profits from Standard Oil Corporation (Rockefeller 347). In 1929, John D. Rockefeller’s wife, Abbey Aldrich Rockefeller, along with two other wealthy patrons, founded the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York City. With her son Nelson, Abbey Rockefeller championed modern art. John D. Rockefeller himself despised modern art, considering it “unlifelike, ugly, and disturbing” (Rockefeller 348). However, despite his reservations, Rockefeller was still a patron of the arts. Rockefeller Center, the scene of the crime, began as a combination of self-interest and philanthropy.
The blocks surrounding the Rockefeller home in New York City were becoming a social problem. “With the advent of prohibition nightclubs and speakeasies selling bootleg liquor appeared” and “there were rumors that a number of brothels had opened as well” (Rockefeller 354). The property was owned by Columbia University, and the majority of the leases were due to expire from 1928-1931. The university wanted to attract the Metropolitan Opera as a tenant for their redevelopment project, and John D. Rockefeller was pulled into the project as a land developer in 1928. The stock market crash of 1929 caused most of the tenants, including the Metropolitan Opera, to pull out. John D. Rockefeller was forced to seek other tenants, including RCA (Rockefeller 355). The shift in economic situation was reflected in the political climate of the country. Communism was on the rise due to the deepening depression. As Peter Hamill puts it:
Groucho Marx said that things were so bad that “the pigeons started feeding people in Central Park.” Those who were not consoled by Groucho sought refuge with Karl. More young people turned to Marxism, and membership in the Communist Party soared to the largest numbers in history (about 80,000). (154)