Crossroads

Man at the Crossroads, photograph by Lucienne Bloch, 1933

During the final week of March, 1933 Diego Rivera began work on a mural for the lobby of RCA Building One in Rockefeller Center. The title, chosen by the architects of the building, was to be Man at the Crossroads Looking with Hope and High Vision to the Choosing of a New and Better Future (Hamill 164). On May 9, 1933 Rivera was fired. The largely unseen public mural was destroyed approximately a year later, after storms of protest. Public art can be a profoundly moving rhetorical act. The differences of opinion surrounding this artwork reward close scrutiny. It was a complex design failure.

The central actors in this drama were the communist painter Diego Rivera and the Rockefeller family. While in retrospect, the combination seems doomed from the onset, the arrangement made sense at the time. The Rockefeller family heritage is filled with both philanthropy and ruthless capitalist practices. John Rockefeller and his son John D. Rockefeller founded the Rockefeller Foundation in 1913 with profits from Standard Oil Corporation (Rockefeller 347). In 1929, John D. Rockefeller’s wife, Abbey Aldrich Rockefeller, along with two other wealthy patrons, founded the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York City. With her son Nelson, Abbey Rockefeller championed modern art. John D. Rockefeller himself despised modern art, considering it “unlifelike, ugly, and disturbing” (Rockefeller 348). However, despite his reservations, Rockefeller was still a patron of the arts. Rockefeller Center, the scene of the crime, began as a combination of self-interest and philanthropy.

The blocks surrounding the Rockefeller home in New York City were becoming a social problem. “With the advent of prohibition nightclubs and speakeasies selling bootleg liquor appeared” and “there were rumors that a number of brothels had opened as well” (Rockefeller 354). The property was owned by Columbia University, and the majority of the leases were due to expire from 1928-1931. The university wanted to attract the Metropolitan Opera as a tenant for their redevelopment project, and John D. Rockefeller was pulled into the project as a land developer in 1928. The stock market crash of 1929 caused most of the tenants, including the Metropolitan Opera, to pull out. John D. Rockefeller was forced to seek other tenants, including RCA (Rockefeller 355). The shift in economic situation was reflected in the political climate of the country. Communism was on the rise due to the deepening depression. As Peter Hamill puts it:

Groucho Marx said that things were so bad that “the pigeons started feeding people in Central Park.” Those who were not consoled by Groucho sought refuge with Karl. More young people turned to Marxism, and membership in the Communist Party soared to the largest numbers in history (about 80,000). (154)

Continue reading “Crossroads” →

License

License

Gary Sauer-Thompson wonders What’s the Fuss? (regarding “faked” photographs from the early twentieth century). His post provides an interesting set of links regarding the work of Frank Hurley on the 1914 expedition to Antarctica. It’s nice to find some corroboration (on a global level) with similar controversies about early American photography—the same sort of charges have been leveled against Arnold Genthe and Edward Sheriff Curtis around roughly the same time. All these controversies are based around the same assumptions. As Gary puts it:

Photographic images cannot be altered seems to be the assumption here. So the manipulation of the images (ie. superimposing images or restaging events) is deemed to be fakery.

This assumes that photography has implicit connotations of authenticity, presupposing that the image is an unmediated transcription of reality. But Hurley rebelled against that view of photography as he used the camera to interpret the world around him.

The presumption of “authenticity” is actually a much later development—I would place it closer to the 1930s. Prior to this time, documentary photographers followed a different set of presumptions first established by documentary sketch artists where composite views were the norm, not the exception. In the US during the Civil War (1861-1965) sketch artists routinely collected views of potential battlefields which were later composited with other material to depict battles which the artist could not possibly have seen. The impetus was to provide a “true depiction” by any means necessary (even when such a depiction was impossible). I find it interesting how frequently CS Pierce, in his writings from 1867-1878, refers to “composite photographs” as if everyone would be familiar with them.

A slight correction to Gary’s observation is in order—Hurley did not so much “rebel” against the presumption of authenticity (because it did not really exist), but rather conformed to the general opinion that interpreted (including manipulated) records were more valuable than “straight” records. It is only our current perspective, looking back after the influence of modernism, which makes Hurley’s efforts seem radical and nonconformist. The first two decades of the twentieth century are profoundly different from the ensuing decades in their normative perception of “authenticity” in images. It was an era of license, where the validity of the observer was not measured by the absence of craft, but rather by its presence.

Convergence

Convergence

The changes in representation and communication which are affecting alphabetic writing have not run their course by any manner of means. The technological changes, as much as the new economic and social conditions which are affecting forms of representation, are still ongoing, at a pace and in directions which will lead to further profound changes. In this respect the convergence of media is a major factor. . . . All we can do at the moment is to look at what there already is, and extrapolate a little; what appears looks very different from that which has been.

The major task is to imagine the characteristics of a theory which can account for the processes of making meaning in the environments of multimodal representation in multimediated communication, of cultural plurality and of social and economic instability. Such a theory will represent a decisive move away from the assumptions of mainstream theories of the last century about meaning, language and learning.

Gunther Kress, Literacy in the New Media Age, 168

I’m not sure about Kress’s assertions here at all. I think that he has targeted the correct “agency”—the convergence of media. I think that he has established the requisite “scene”—the flux of cultural change which destabilizes acts of representation. However, Kress makes little mention of the “actors” involved. Who is it that makes meaning? Obviously, given that the book is targeted at educators, Kress might assume that teachers do. That isn’t necessarily a safe assumption.

In “The Impact of the Internet and Digital Technologies on Teaching and Research in Technical Communication” (in the latest TCQ), Laura Gurak and Ann Duin suggest that the slow adoption of technology in academia opens a window of opportunity for corporate vocational educators to compete with traditional academic “providers” of education. I think this is a more “decisive move” than the move away from the supposed “assumptions of mainstream theories” regarding meaning, language, and learning. The core of the movement (which manifests itself in many ways across the twentieth century) is based on pragmatic view of meaning—learning is something that earns “profit” in some form. The convergence of media is seen, by both learners and providers, as an agency for economic, rather than social change. The basic yardstick for vocational education is that of “competence”— learners are tested for their ability to perform tasks.

Kress suggests that this sort of thinking should be replaced with a more “design oriented” mode:

The notion of competence in use will give way to that of interested design. Competence in use starts with that which exists, shaped by the social history of the group in which the user acts. Hence competence in use is oriented to the past. It is also oriented to allegiance to the conventions of the group. Design, by contrast, starts from the interest and intent of the designer to act in a specific way in a specific environment, to act with a set of available resources and to act with an understanding of what the task at hand is, in relation to a specific audience. Design is prospective, future-oriented: in this environment, with these (multiple) resources, and out of my interests now to act newly I will shape a message. (169)

From 1900-1940, photographic educators published as many books about “composition” (design) as they did about “grammar” (chemical processes). Their approach to design was sophisticated and comprehensive. Many of the books were about a very specific type of technical communication (advertising), and the lessons there say a lot about the confluence of media types. I do not believe that the emphasis on design promoted by Kress is nearly so new and revolutionary as he thinks it is. We went through all this at the turn of the previous century. It doesn’t really look that different to me at all. The emphasis on design is not, in my opinion, a purely “future-directed” phenomenon. Design is as much about establishing continuity with the past as it is solving problems in the present. This sense of continuity is missing from most of the discourse about “new media.” Some things are different, yes, but the basic theories? I really don’t think they’ve changed all that much—I think we need to find the convergences as much as the divergences.

Thesis

Moving Ahead

I suppose I need to change my about page soon. Now, I have at least one thing in common with Ron Jeremy. All the forms are in, and I should be receiving my Master’s degree soon. While I suspect that it will not interest most people, I uploaded a PDF of my thesis. At 2.7 megs, expect it to take a while if you try to grab it on a slow connection.

The best compliments I got on it were from my committee, who each claimed that it taught them a lot they didn’t know. I chose my committee carefully. My chair was a specialist in discourse pragmatics from the Rhetoric Department. The other two people were from radically different departments—Jim Levernier from the English Department and Gary Cawood from the Art Department. Jim specializes in American literature, particularly the marginalized literatures of the eighteenth century. Gary is a photographer who is deeply concerned with the connections between photography and literature. All of them are well respected senior faculty. I figured if I could impress them, I must be doing something right.

Using such a diverse committee meant that I couldn’t take much for granted as far as a “common background” goes. Everything I explored had to be explained carefully and clearly, otherwise it just wouldn’t make any sense. I feel like I was more successful in some sections of the thesis than others, and I have a nagging feeling that I just didn’t do enough. But as it is, it is one of the longest theses produced from my department since its inception. I felt really bad about dropping such a “book” on people, but it took a lot of careful consideration to make myself sure that I was on a viable track. I wanted confirmation across several disciplines that I had a usable framework for discussing words and images.

In some ways, this thesis is an exercise in hair-splitting that challenges, most of all, the concept of syntax as it as applied to word and image. I think that accepting the non-Euclidian spatial aspects of syntax moves us closer to understanding how we make meaning. Of course it does more than that—if you’re curious, you can always read it.

Defensible

Defensible

I just received word from my committee chair that I am ready to defend my Master’s thesis, probably this Thursday. I feel kind of strange about it. I’ve resisted tweaking on the draft until I see the final comments, but from what he said it shouldn’t take more than a couple of hours to get polished. In an email comment, he said that I might deal with Kenneth Burke a little more. I could write another chapter on Burke really, but . . . he said: “Don’t do that! Just call it done.”

That’s the hardest part, really. It doesn’t really feel done. It feels started.

The whole process was surprisingly painless. I didn’t have to go through many revisions, really, in the grand scheme. Editing other people’s manuscripts is much harder. Most of the changes were instigated by me, not by members of my committee. I was reading The Rule of Metaphor by Paul Ricoeur again last night (for the tenth or twelfth time), and his treatment of Augustine struck a chord. Making an argument about meaning (in my case) or time (in Augustine’s case) is like fighting a hydra. Every time you chop off one head, another one rises up to take a bite out of you. Ricouer’s statement that closes the appendix rings truer to me now than ever:

What happens in the far more intricate cases of text-interpretation and what constitutes the key problem of hermeneutics is already foreshadowed in the interpretive process as it occurs in ordinary language. Thus, the whole problem of text-interpretation could be renewed by the recognition of its roots in the functioning of ordinary language itself.

Such are the problems I am now working and reflecting on.

I believe that “ordinary language’” is not exclusively linguistic. It contains visual and gestural elements that cannot be accounted for via strict textual analysis. I think this is inextricably tied to our sense of time. Image/texts highlight just how little we understand the spatiality and temporality. Neither space nor time is the exclusive providence of either mode. Time, in particular, is the most complex problem. We live in Augustine’s threefold present, I think; this forces us to process everything based on a presumption of what was, a limited appreciation of what is, and an anticipation of what we want to be.

Of course, it goes without saying that I didn’t even mention Ricoeur or Augustine in my thesis; they were among many things floating around in my head as I was writing. The damn thing had about 90 sources which I mentioned, and probably around 900 that I didn’t.

Random Bits

Random Bits

  • via 2 Blowhards — Counter Culture: Parisian Cabarets and the Avant Garde, 1875-1905

    A quite interesting look at café culture prior to the World Wars. Of course, it is credited as a response to the Franco Prussian War (1870). I wonder if there is any cultural phenomenon that cannot be connected as a reaction to war? It seems to me that we need a new model for forging cultures.

  • New Walker Evans prints discovered

    Of course, they found them in the backroom of a bar in Key West. CNN news story here. Cubanet news story here. Florida Keys news story here. The thank you, in this case, goes to the girlfriend.

  • via datacloud — Early Visual Media.

    This one kind of pissed me off a little, because it is yet another attempt to lock-up vintage imagery behind modern copyright. However it is a great site with lots of interesting images and is very well done.

  • via Kairosnews — Hey Hey 16k thanks Matt!

    Unfortunately, I actually remember most of this quite clearly. “For N = 0 to 2; those were the days, indeed.”

Just trying to clear out my “surflog” links into a more archive friendly form.

Definitions

Definitions

As we thought about the definitional problems surrounding the study of visual rhetoric, it became immediately clear that the appropriate response was not to try to “nail down” the term, to stipulate a set of definitions that all rhetoricians would agree to abide by (a na�ve notion, to say the least). Rather, we thought it would be more interesting and productive to have scholars working with visuals discuss the definitional assumptions behind their own work, and to exemplify these assumptions by sharing their own rhetorical analyses of visual phenomena. Our own assumptions behind this approach are two-fold. First any discussion of definitions from which one is operating is necessarily post-hoc; that is, one discovers such definitional assumptions through the work, rather than explicating them (even to oneself) before approaching a scholarly project. Second, at this very early stage in the contemporary study of visual rhetoric, we assume that people are more interested in writing about and in reading about specific scholarly projects than in lengthy arguments about definitions.

Charles A. Hill and Marguerite Helmer, introduction to Defining Visual Rhetorics (2004)

As usual, I’m behind the curve—this is precisely the opposite of what I’ve been up to. I’ve been interested in definitions. I put my entire project on hold, as a matter of fact, while I worked on reading image /text theories to come up with a more workable framework for discussing their interaction. I’m tired of reading endless analyses of visual phenomena written from poorly fitted theoretical frames.

Starting with my studies in William Blake (now three years gone) I was really dissatisfied with most of the existing frameworks—and a better one really didn’t leap out at me while I was studying the work. I was never able to look back at the 60-70 pages worth of unfinished text I generated and say “oh, that’s what I was doing!” What it was, (in case you’re curious), was an attempt to do visual/textual analysis based on the gestural rhetorics of the nineteenth century. It was as inconclusive as most things written about Blake generally are. I think it suffered most from a lack of definition.

When I started dealing with photography (more comfortable terrain for me) I was even more dissatisfied with the traditional cultural/Marxist frameworks. That’s when I started digging more into linguistics and the semantics/pragmatics interface. I found in linguistics a more rigorous frame with more precise definitions. Though there is as little consensus in linguistics as there is in rhetoric, at least the terms seemed to translate better than the loaded vocabulary of cultural criticism. The Hill / Helmers collection is one of the best I’ve seen to date though—it at least takes notice, through the variety of its contributions, of the multiplicity of preexisting theories on the subject. I don’t agree that visual rhetoric is new at all—but it certainly is a stranger to coherence.

In the linguistic theories I’d like to bring to bear on the problem, there may not be agreement—but at least there is coherence. Unfortunately, now as I edit the 90 page manuscript, I find that I spent very little time really talking about pictures. That makes me sad. But hopefully, I’ve got a few years to work on that problem—now that I have definitions that I am comfortable with.

“New” Media

Literacy in the New Media Age

Gunther Kress’s latest book offers some appraisals regarding the landscape of multimodal discourse. I agree, but with historical reservations:

One might say the following with some confidence. Language-as-speech will remain the major mode of communication; language-as-writing will increasingly be displaced in many domains of public communication, though writing will remain the preferred mode of the political and cultural elites. The combined effects on writing of the dominance of the mode of image and of the medium of the screen will produce deep changes in the forms and functions of writing. This in turn will have profound effects on human, cognitive/affective, cultural, and bodily engagement with the world, and on the forms and shapes of knowledge. The world told is a different world to the world shown. (Kress, 2003, p1.).

Kress’s pronouncement of a shifting, increasingly image based media landscape is parallel to other observations regarding new media. Kathleen Welch observed, and I believe rightly so, that the landscape of television is based in aural communication. Few people can “make sense” from television without its accompanying soundtrack—while people frequently surf the Internet with the sound turned off, reliant on image-based or textual cues, rather than auditory ones. Though both media are “screen-based,” they are distinctly different in epistemic use. Television immerses us in a non-interactive spectatorship, while the computer is dependent on our interaction with it. The implications of both screen-based media among “political and cultural elites,” however, is often based in what W.J.T. Mitchell characterized as “iconophobia”—a fear of the effects of a reliance on images to transmit knowledge. To his credit, Kress characterizes this shift as a matter of “gains and losses” rather than an overwhelmingly negative cognitive impact.

What is overlooked in this insistence on the “newness” of the media landscape is the complexity of eighteenth and nineteenth print culture—our previous landscape, which is not so distant from this debate in many respects. Across new media scholarship, there is a tendency to discount the role of images in past epistemés, as if these questions had not been addressed before. Rather than acknowledge any continuity with past practices, the new landscape is characterized as a rupture from a stereotypical, recited by rote, history of print culture. Rhetoric is also often cast as a monomodal discipline, focused on text or speech alone—though rhetoric’s ties to writing are almost exclusively a twentieth century formulation.

Continue reading ““New” Media” →

Touchstones

Touchstones

Camille Paglia’s latest article on visual rhetoric really made me laugh. It’s as if the ghost of Mathew Arnold constantly mocks us from beyond the grave. Besides being downright uninformed, it outlines a sort of cultural conservatism that really deserves to die. Just a few snips to fisk out briefly:

Post-structuralism and postmodernism do not understand magic or mystique, which are intrinsic to art and imagination. It is no coincidence that since postmodernist terminology seeped into the art world in the 1980s, the fine arts have receded as a major cultural force.

Surely Ms. Paglia has read Roland Barthes or Baudrillard. This is beyond absurd. One could more easily argue that Clement Greenberg and high modernism “killed” the notion of a culturally effective art, and that post-modernism was only dancing on its grave. This ignorance is minor, however, compared to her horrible grasp of physiology:

The eyes are neurologically tied to the entire vestibular system: the conch-like inner ear facilitates hand-eye coordination and gives us direction and balance in the physical world. By processing depth cues, our eyes orient us in space and create and confirm our sense of individual agency. Those in whom eye movements and vestibular equilibrium are disrupted, I contend, cannot sense context and thus become passive to the world, which they do not see as an arena for action. Hence this perceptual problem may well have unwelcome political consequences.

Are blind people (who have no sense of visual equilibrium) somehow more passive and unable to discern context? Do they lack a sense of individual agency? This is beyond ludicrous, but not nearly so laughable as Paglia’s “cure”:

To maintain order, the choice of representative images will need to be stringently narrowed. I envision a syllabus based on key images that would give teachers great latitude to expand the verbal dimension of presentation, including an analysis of style as well as a narrative of personal response.

So, the key to dealing with media overload is to act like it doesn’t exist and dredge up some canonical moments of peace and serenity? The students gather around in togas while the teacher pontificates on the nature of classical beauty? I can’t picture a quicker way to send them off in a dead run looking for the nearest TV or Internet connection. This article goes immediately to the top of my list of worst essays ever written on visual rhetoric.

As I was tempted to say when I first read Mathew Arnold, “I got your touchstones hangin!”

Gains and Losses

Gains and Losses

I had never heard of Gunther Kress until a month ago. Alan Gross, soon to be my advisor, mentioned that I really should look at Reading Images. The book hadn’t arrived before I traveled to Minnesota, but another of his titles, Multimodal Discourse, did. I read it in a hurry while I was in Michigan, and didn’t like it much at all. It seemed downright retrograde compared to most of the scholarship I’ve been reading about text and image. When I got to Minnesota, Art Walzer mentioned Kress too. I figured I should do my best to give it fair consideration, but it was hard—I really didn’t like his approach at all. It seemed far too complex, with meaningless categories (okay for print culture, but ill-suited to electronic discourse).

My primary critique was twofold: Kress is an essentialist (words and pictures are essentially different) and Multimodal Discourse insists that production and distribution were essentially different phenomenon (okay, I’ll agree as far as print goes but I don’t think that really applies to electronic discourse). I mentioned this to Gross, and he granted that it was a valid critique. When I got home, Reading Images had arrived. It explained a lot about his approach—Kress’s approach is sociological, and based on Halliday’s functional linguistics. As an alternative to Chomsky’s transformational approach, Halliday felt that grammar was socially determined. Researching Halliday a bit, it seemed clear that this sort of approach is an alternate (top-down rather than bottom-up) way of looking at language. Both perspectives might be valid— they do not invalidate each other, they just look at the problem of grammar from two different directions. But still, Kress’s approach just didn’t click for me.

When I got to C’s, I discovered that Kress was a featured speaker. His presentation was called “Gains and Losses: New Forms of Texts, Knowledge, and Learning.” I was impressed by the man far more than I was impressed by his ideas. In the question and answer period after his lecture, other people raised the same questions I had weeks before—can we really generalize about texts and images in this fashion?

Continue reading “Gains and Losses” →