An alternative view from James Burke:
Category: Visual Rhetoric
Like finding a clue
Storytelling (2)
In the nineteenth century, a number of technological innovations forever altered the way we conceive of stories and the way that we tell them. These innovations can be placed within the context of a much older story—the history of writing technologies—but doing that tends to occlude as much as it illuminates. To speak of the impact of visual innovation on print technology (perhaps becoming the central change of the eighteenth century) generally positions the role of alternative information sources as servants to alphabetic literacy. In reality, there were entirely unique modes of circulation and valuation for prints that operated independently of the venues for books. This observation seldom occurs in most scholarship outside of art history. Then, as now, there were literacies that were cultivated apart from the venues of verbal riposte.
Literacies beyond spoken and written language were fundamentally altered by the process of technological change. These literacies might better be considered independent rather dependent on the comfortable cohesion that the unquestioned centrality of language provides. But there’s the rub—language is the only communicative meaning that is extensible and generalizable in a way that can hope to capture the nuances of such changes in the form of critique. In fact, language is commonly believed to be commensurate with thought itself so much so that images and/or experiences can be dispensed with entirely. Witness this bit from a preface to a recent French art history text translated by Art History Newsletter:
Becoming Authority
When I first taught first year writing in Arkansas, I took a cue from my literature background and required the students to write a bibliographic essay in order to establish the distinction between research and opinion. I expressly forbade offering excessive opinion about their sources; I wanted them to place the sources into some relationship with one another. The results were mixed. I got a lot of opinions.
I changed my approach just a bit this time. One of my grad instructors in Minnesota last year required an annotated bibliography and I was confused—I wrote a bibliographic essay instead, and was forced to revise it to fit the alternate form. It dawned on me that an annotated bibliography is a completely different animal that is noticeably easier to write than a bibliographic essay. No relationships are required; an annotated bibliography is simply a string of summaries. When we organize things, opinions seem to be the requisite glue to hold things together. I could more easily eliminate the opinions by eliminating the creative possibilities inherent in structure.
Bone Lens
Georgia O’Keefe, Pelvis I (Pelvis with Blue), 1944, oil on canvas, 36″ x 30″I see so many things, a primitive ring,
a nest with a fallen-out bottom,
a white rubber band snapped into blue.
But mostly it’s real memory
and the doctor holding up my x-ray
to the screen of light, a mini drive-in.
. . .Denise Duhamel,
Reminded of my Biological Clock — While Looking at Georgia O’Keefe’s Pelvis One
Last week we went to go see Georgia O’Keefe: Circling around Abstraction at the Minneapolis Institute of the Arts. It was disappointing, given that there were only 42 or so works displayed and they charged a premium for entry. Looking at the video online from the same show at the Norton Museum, it seems as if there were a lot of works missing. I didn’t buy the monograph, but I had wondered why there even was a monograph given the less than earth-shattering premiseof the unremarkable collection. The really interesting thing to me isn’t simply that O’Keefe “circled” abstraction, but that she steadfastly refused to land. The primary reason usually given is that she was horrified by the interpretations attached to her abstract works by critics.
But the show made me think just the same. One of the placards referred to the pelvis series as an exploration of the “bone lens.” This phrase has stuck in my head for several days now. A quote purported to be from a 1944 exhibition catalog tends to support this quirky interpretation of the pelvic bone paintings:
Spam Gate

One thing that always bothers me about the weekend is being forced to watch Fox to get local coverage. However, yesterday evening there was an interesting story about a local “meat sculptor” who entertains herself during the cold weather by making spam candles, hot-dog necklaces and such. I looked at the Fox web site to see if there was any mention of the story or web links and found that they do not update the site on weekends. So I googled around, and found the wonderful sculpture displayed above (completely unrelated to the story).
The spam sculpture of Anish Kapoor’s Cloud Gate warmed my heart. It’s from 2005, the same year I presented a paper on the legal and social controversies surrounding public photography of this sculpture at the Sweetland writing conference in Ann Arbor, Michigan. The paper is supposed to be included in a forthcoming anthology. I wish I had known of this fabulous sculpture then; I might have included it in my presentation.
Haas (plural)
I became strangely obsessed with Chocolate Haas by Sander Plug. It seemed that for a day at least, everywhere I turned there was a Haas of some variant or another. On the CBS evening news, Richard Haass suggested that GW has to tone down his rhetoric about Iran now that there is no evidence of a nuclear conspiracy. Trying to figure out who he was, I stumbled on Richard Haas, a wonderful painter of trompe-l’œil works on the sides of buildings. An odd confluence, triggered by a melting chocolate bunny. Each in its own way involves a magic trick.
I suppose what really drew me into the film was the emotional nature of what is essentially a good science project for a ten-year-old boy. The beauty of the collapse leaves you feeling oddly guilty that you find it aesthetically pleasing. Ruins have that sort of pleasure: the scars of misfortune find a sort of resonance to people constantly under assault from the new. There’s a question of course, “what would happen if,” that seems to underwrite such experiments with ruin. In that sense, the piece seems to be as much an experiment as a beautiful object. The remix with a death metal soundtrack recasts it in a different adolescent milieu.
The beauty is strictly in the facade; underneath the bunny is hollow. It’s a moving trompe-l’œil, disappearing in moments before our eyes. But perhaps it owes its impact to a visual variant of the Haas effect—the first sense impression persists, even as the contradictory impressions flood across the visual field.
Historic Heads
The Anglo-Saxon period, which, in respect of Art, seems to mingle both classical reminiscences and Byzantine traditions with a grandly fantastic native element, offers more interest. Christ is here more strictly separate; the disciples have one class of features, being chiefly given with classically formed profiles, the angels and archangels another, and Christ a third. This is of an abstract and weird character, conveying a strange sense of the supernatural, perfectly in keeping with the abstract nature of the more general conception, which represents our Lord in glory. The head rises grandly above the stony stare, the divided hair is cinctured with a fillet and jewel, and the beard is formed into three points. The lines are few and equal, as if by a hand accustomed to incise them in a harder material. Another form, with a bushy wig of hair, of which we annex an illustration (No. 11), is more fantastic, though not without a certain grandeur. This is taken from an Anglo-Saxon MS. In the British Museum, of the year 1000.
. . .Our next specimen (No 13, over leaf) is English in origin, taken from a psalter (Biblila Regia, 2 A. XXII,. In the Biritish Museum, of about the year 1250). This is reduced from a head half the size of life. Here the fact that the type of Christ’s head is the same as contemporary persons is strikingly borne out, for the head of Henry III (1216-72). discovered on the wall of the Windsor cloisters, is curiously identical in form an expression though more rude.
Affective Education (1)
Back in 1977, I attempted attending Bakersfield College, a.k.a. “the high school on the hill” or “Panorama High,” a two-year community college with free tuition. It was the only choice I had as a poor boy. I only made it for a year, even though I had what many teenage boys might call a dream job—I was paid to photograph pornographic magazines. I was an assistant to the P.R. photographer on campus, Al Noriega, but mainly I worked with instructional materials (specifically Swedish ones). After taking the usual panorama of psychology, philosophy, and art classes I dropped out in disgust when I was not able to pass even the bonehead English course. I could read, but I couldn’t write. So I jumped ship.
Rex called me the other day to inform me about their latest P.R. campaign distributed around the city on billboards. As with many things, location is the key to success. Where this billboard was placed is especially meaningful to folks of my vintage.
Strike the Profile
A Syracuse University graduate student taking photographs outside the VA Medical Center says she was questioned and ordered to delete several images by hospital security officers Thursday afternoon.
Mariam Jukaku, 24, of Michigan, said the officers also photocopied her university ID and driver’s license and asked if she was a U.S. citizen. She wonders if her appearance played a part in how the incident was handled.
Jukaku, a U.S. citizen of Indian descent, said she is Muslim and wears a head scarf.